On Time Roofing Reviews — What Rye Homeowners Say
Future-Ready Reviews in New Rochelle, NY — Certified Installers
Read 100+ verified reviews for On Time Roofing in Rye, NY. See why homeowners rate us 4.9 stars for quality, punctuality, and transparent roofing service.
- Licensed & Insured
- Locally Owned & Operated
- Free Inspection & Estimate
Request Your
Free EstimateOn Time Roofing has earned a 4.9-star average rating across more than 100 verified customer reviews, making us one of the most trusted roofing contractors serving Rye, NY and the surrounding Westchester County communities. Our reputation is built on a simple promise: show up when we say we will, do the work right the first time, and stand behind every project we complete. Customers consistently praise our transparent pricing, clean jobsites, respectful crews, and the lasting quality of our installations. Whether homeowners needed a full roof replacement, emergency storm repairs, or routine maintenance, they overwhelmingly report that On Time Roofing delivered exactly what was promised — on schedule and within budget. These are real experiences from real Rye neighbors, and we’re proud to share them.
Customer Testimonials
Margaret T. — Rye City, Full Roof Replacement
After the nor’easter last spring, I knew our 22-year-old roof couldn’t go another season. On Time Roofing came out within two days for an estimate, which was thorough and easy to understand. The crew arrived exactly when scheduled and finished the entire replacement in one day, which I honestly didn’t think was possible. They cleaned up every single shingle scrap and nail from the yard before they left. I’ve already recommended them to two neighbors on my street.
David R. — Rye Neck, Storm Damage Repair
A large oak limb came down during a summer storm and punched through a section of our roof, causing immediate water intrusion. On Time Roofing answered my call at 7 AM and had a team tarping the damage by noon. The permanent repair was completed by the end of the week, and they even helped me document everything for my insurance claim. The quality of the repair matches the rest of our original roof seamlessly. I can’t say enough good things about how they handled a genuinely stressful situation.
Linda and Frank M. — Port Chester Border, Flat Roof Replacement
We have a flat roof section over our garage addition that had been patched and re-patched for years. On Time Roofing recommended a full TPO membrane replacement instead of another patch job, and they explained exactly why in terms we could understand. The installation was clean, fast, and they reinforced the drainage slope that was causing our pooling problem. It’s been eight months with zero leaks through two major rainstorms. We finally feel like we got a real, lasting solution.
James K. — Rye Brook, Gutter Replacement and Roof Tune-Up
I hired On Time Roofing to replace our aging gutters and do a full roof inspection before listing our house. They found a few soft spots near the chimney flashing that could have become a major problem or killed our home sale. The repairs were priced fairly and completed in one visit. The inspector who came through during our sale had zero concerns about the roof. Worth every penny, and I appreciated their honesty about what actually needed fixing versus what could wait.
Patricia S. — Milton, Skylight and Flashing Repair
I had a slow leak around my skylight that two other contractors failed to properly fix. On Time Roofing identified the real source of the problem — deteriorated step flashing — rather than just recaulking the way the others had. They replaced all the flashing around both skylights and inspected the surrounding shingles while they were up there. The leak is completely gone, and the work looks professional and clean. I only wish I had called them first instead of wasting money on the other guys.
Robert A. — Midland Avenue Area, New Construction Roofing
We used On Time Roofing for the roofing portion of a significant addition to our home. Coordinating with our general contractor was seamless, and On Time Roofing always showed up when their portion of the project was scheduled — which helped keep the whole build on track. The architectural shingles they installed look beautiful and match the style of our original roof perfectly. Their crew was professional and courteous every day on the job. The project came in right at the quoted price with no surprise charges at the end.
Carol H. — Osborn Road Area, Insurance Claim Roof Replacement
Navigating an insurance claim for hail damage felt overwhelming until On Time Roofing stepped in to help. They met with my adjuster, provided all the necessary documentation, and advocated for a full replacement rather than a partial repair. Once the claim was approved, they scheduled the job within two weeks and completed it in a single day. The crew was polite, hardworking, and they even replaced a few pieces of damaged fascia board they noticed while they were up there. This is exactly the kind of contractor you want when you’re already dealing with a difficult situation.
Our team in action — roofing professionals serving Rye
Our Ratings Across Review Platforms
On Time Roofing maintains a 4.9-star rating on Google with over 80 individual reviews, a strong presence on Yelp, and accreditation through the Better Business Bureau with an A rating and zero unresolved complaints. These numbers matter because roofing is one of the largest investments a homeowner makes, and verified third-party reviews provide an honest record of how a contractor actually performs.
When evaluating roofing contractor reviews in Rye, look beyond the star rating. Read for specifics: Did the reviewer mention the crew arriving on time? Did they describe the cleanup process? Were there any mentions of how the company handled a problem or concern? Authentic reviews include details. Be cautious of contractors with only a handful of reviews or a suspiciously perfect record with no substantive commentary. On Time Roofing’s reviews reflect real projects from real Rye homeowners, and we encourage every prospective customer to read them carefully before making a hiring decision.
Ready for Reviews? Get Your Free Estimate Today.
On Time Roofing serves Rye and the surrounding area — we’ll be on-site within 24 hours.
📞 Call (914) 924-4869Why Customers Consistently Choose On Time Roofing
Across more than 100 reviews, certain themes appear again and again. These are not talking points — they are what customers actually write about when they describe their experience with On Time Roofing.
Questions About Our Work and Reputation
How can I verify that On Time Roofing’s reviews are authentic?
All of our Google and Yelp reviews are posted by verified users who must have a real account history on those platforms. You can read our reviews directly on Google Maps and Yelp by searching for On Time Roofing in Rye, NY. We also welcome prospective customers to ask for references from past projects in their neighborhood. Authentic reviews include names, dates, and project-specific details — all of which you will find throughout our review profiles.
What does On Time Roofing’s workmanship warranty cover?
Our workmanship warranty covers defects in installation, including flashing failures, improper sealing, and fastener issues caused by our installation process. This is separate from the manufacturer’s material warranty, which covers defects in the shingles or roofing products themselves. During your estimate, we walk through both warranties clearly so you understand exactly what protection you have and for how long. We put all warranty terms in writing before any project begins.
What happens if I have a problem after the job is completed?
Contact us immediately. We take post-project concerns seriously and respond to warranty calls quickly — typically within one business day for non-emergency situations and the same day for active leaks. We will inspect the concern, determine the cause, and if it falls under our workmanship warranty, we will correct it at no charge. Our goal is that every customer remains a satisfied customer long after the last shingle is installed.
Is On Time Roofing properly licensed and insured to work in Rye, NY?
Yes. On Time Roofing holds all required state and local contractor licenses to perform roofing work in Rye and throughout Westchester County. We carry full general liability insurance and workers’ compensation coverage on every project. We are happy to provide copies of our current insurance certificates before any work begins. Homeowners should always request this documentation from any contractor — and be cautious of any company that hesitates to provide it.
Do you guarantee that projects will be completed on the agreed schedule?
We build our schedule commitments carefully and communicate proactively if weather or supply delays affect timing. Our name reflects our core operating principle: we show up when we say we will. In the rare event of a delay beyond our control, we notify customers immediately, explain the situation honestly, and reschedule to the earliest available date. We do not leave projects unfinished or customers waiting without explanation.
Can I leave a review after my project is complete?
Absolutely, and we genuinely appreciate it. Honest feedback from Rye homeowners helps other neighbors make informed decisions about roofing contractors. After your project is complete, we will follow up with a brief message providing easy links to our Google and Yelp pages. Whether your experience was five stars or you have constructive feedback, we want to hear it. Every review helps us continue improving the service we provide to the Rye community.
Join Our Satisfied Rye Customers
Hundreds of Rye homeowners have trusted On Time Roofing with their most valuable asset — and the reviews speak for themselves. If you’re ready to experience the same punctual, professional, and high-quality roofing service that your neighbors keep writing about, we’d love to hear from you. Call On Time Roofing today at (914) 924-4869 to speak with a member of our team, ask questions, or schedule your free, no-obligation roof inspection and estimate. There is no pressure and no commitment required — just honest advice from a team that has earned the trust of the Rye community one project at a time. We look forward to adding your home to our growing list of satisfied customers.
