On Time Roofing Reviews — What New Rochelle Homeowners Say
Future-Ready Reviews in New Rochelle, NY — Certified Installers
Read 100+ verified reviews of On Time Roofing in New Rochelle, NY. See why homeowners rate us 4.9 stars for roof replacement, repairs, and more.
- Licensed & Insured
- Locally Owned & Operated
- Free Inspection & Estimate
Request Your
Free EstimateOn Time Roofing has earned a 4.9-star rating across more than 100 verified reviews from homeowners throughout New Rochelle, NY. Our reputation is built on one simple promise: showing up when we say we will and delivering roofing work that lasts. Customers consistently praise our transparent pricing, clean job sites, and the quality of materials we use on every project. Whether it’s an emergency repair after a storm or a full roof replacement, reviewers highlight our professionalism, clear communication from start to finish, and our team’s genuine respect for their homes. From Pelham Manor Road to the North End, New Rochelle homeowners trust On Time Roofing to protect what matters most — and our reviews prove it.
Customer Testimonials
Maria S. — Wykagyl, Full Roof Replacement
After the storms last spring, I knew my 20-year-old roof couldn’t hold up another season. On Time Roofing came out within two days for an inspection and gave me a written estimate the same afternoon. The crew arrived exactly when they said they would and finished the full replacement in one day. My yard was completely spotless when they left — not a single nail in sight. I’ve already recommended them to three neighbors on my block.
David K. — Beechmont, Storm Damage Repair
A falling branch during a nor’easter punched a hole clean through two sections of my roof. I called On Time Roofing at 7 AM and they had someone out by noon with a temporary cover to stop the leaking. The permanent repair was scheduled and completed within the week. They worked directly with my insurance adjuster, which took an enormous amount of stress off my plate. Honest, fast, and fairly priced — exactly what you need in an emergency.
Patricia L. — Residence Near Memorial Highway, Flat Roof Installation
I own a converted carriage house with a flat roof that had been patched so many times it was embarrassing. On Time Roofing recommended a modern TPO membrane system and explained exactly why it was the right fit for my structure. The installation was seamless and the team answered every question I had without making me feel rushed. That was eighteen months ago and the roof has performed perfectly through two hard winters. I wouldn’t go to anyone else.
James R. — North End, Chimney Flashing and Shingle Repair
Water was getting in around my chimney and staining the ceiling in my upstairs hallway. I got three quotes and On Time Roofing was the only contractor who actually got on the roof to look at the flashing before giving me a number. They diagnosed the real problem instead of just selling me new shingles I didn’t need. The repair was done in a few hours and the price matched the estimate exactly. No surprises, no upselling — just solid work.
Angela T. — Echo Bay Area, Gutter Replacement with Roofing Work
We had On Time Roofing replace the rear section of our roof that had been damaged and also replace our aging gutters at the same time. Coordinating both jobs with one contractor made everything so much easier. The team was respectful of our landscaping, which I really appreciated since we’d just redone the garden. Everything was completed on schedule and within budget. The gutters and roof have handled every rainstorm this season without a drip.
Robert M. — Huguenot Park, New Roof on Investment Property
As a landlord with a rental property in New Rochelle, I needed a roofing contractor I could rely on without being on-site every minute. On Time Roofing communicated with me by phone and sent photos throughout the project so I always knew where things stood. The tenants told me the crew was professional and quiet. The job came in on time and under the deadline I needed for a lease renewal. I’ll be using them on my other properties going forward.
Christine B. — Pelham Road Corridor, Emergency Leak Repair
I came home to a bucket in my living room and a steadily growing water stain on a Friday afternoon. On Time Roofing answered immediately, sent a tech over within the hour, and had the source of the leak identified and temporarily sealed before dark. They came back Monday morning to complete the permanent fix with quality materials. The response time genuinely surprised me — I’ve been ignored by other contractors for days. These folks actually care about your home.
Thomas and Ellen V. — Gedney Farms, Full Architectural Shingle Replacement
Our home is one of the older colonials in the neighborhood and we wanted architectural shingles that matched the character of the house. The team at On Time Roofing walked us through several options with samples and didn’t push the most expensive product. The installation crew was skilled, efficient, and clearly experienced with older home construction. The finished roof looks beautiful and we’ve received compliments from neighbors we’ve never even spoken to before. Worth every penny.
Our team in action — roofing professionals serving New Rochelle
Our Ratings Across Review Platforms
On Time Roofing maintains a 4.9-star average on Google Reviews, where over 100 verified New Rochelle homeowners have shared their experiences. We are also proud members of the Better Business Bureau, holding an A-rated accreditation that reflects our commitment to ethical business practices and responsive customer service. Our Yelp profile features additional verified reviews from Westchester County homeowners across a range of project types and price points.
When hiring a roofing contractor in New Rochelle, verified reviews are one of your most powerful tools. Look for reviews that mention specific project types, timelines, and follow-up service — not just general praise. Pay attention to how a company responds to any negative feedback, which reveals far more about their character than five-star reviews alone. Cross-reference ratings across multiple platforms to get the most complete picture. A contractor with consistent, detailed, and recent reviews across Google, BBB, and Yelp is far more trustworthy than one with a single high rating on a single site. Our transparent review history speaks for itself.
Ready for Reviews? Get Your Free Estimate Today.
On Time Roofing serves New Rochelle and the surrounding area — we’ll be on-site within 24 hours.
📞 Call (914) 924-4869Why Customers Consistently Choose On Time Roofing
Our reviews aren’t just high — they’re specific. When New Rochelle homeowners write about their experience with On Time Roofing, they come back to the same themes time and again. Here is what our customers say sets us apart:
Questions About Our Work and Reputation
How can I verify that your reviews are real?
All of our Google and Yelp reviews come from verified accounts tied to real homeowners in the New Rochelle and greater Westchester area. You can view our full review history directly on those platforms at any time. We also encourage prospective customers to ask us for references from past projects in their specific neighborhood so they can speak directly with a neighbor who has used our services.
What does your workmanship warranty cover?
Our workmanship warranty covers any defects in installation or labor for a minimum of five years on standard roofing projects. Manufacturer warranties on shingles and roofing materials are separate and can extend up to 30 years depending on the product selected. We walk every customer through both warranties in writing before the project begins so there are no questions about what is and isn’t covered.
What happens if something goes wrong after the job is finished?
If you experience any issue related to our work after project completion, contact us directly and we will send a technician to evaluate the situation — typically within 48 hours. If the issue falls under our workmanship warranty, we will repair it at no charge. We do not argue about warranty claims or require homeowners to jump through hoops. Our goal is your long-term satisfaction, and we stand behind every job we complete.
How do I verify that On Time Roofing is properly licensed and insured in New York?
On Time Roofing is fully licensed to perform roofing work in Westchester County and the State of New York, and we carry full general liability insurance as well as workers’ compensation coverage. We are happy to provide copies of our license and insurance certificates before any work begins. You can also verify our BBB standing independently. Working with an unlicensed or uninsured roofer puts your home and your finances at serious legal and financial risk — always verify before signing a contract.
Do you offer any satisfaction guarantee beyond the written warranty?
Yes. We are not satisfied until you are satisfied. If at any point during or immediately after your project you have concerns about the quality of work, we will address them before finalizing payment. Our goal is to earn a five-star review because we genuinely delivered five-star service — not because a job was technically completed. We welcome walkthroughs with homeowners at the end of every project to confirm everything meets expectations.
Can I read reviews from homeowners in my specific neighborhood?
Absolutely. Many of our Google reviews include neighborhood references throughout New Rochelle, from Wykagyl and Beechmont to the North End and Echo Bay. You can filter or search reviews to find projects similar to yours. We have completed work across virtually every neighborhood in New Rochelle and can often connect you with a specific reference in your area upon request.
Join Our Satisfied New Rochelle Customers
Over 100 New Rochelle homeowners have trusted On Time Roofing with their most important investment — their home. Now it’s your turn. Whether you need a full roof replacement, storm damage repair, or a professional inspection before the next season hits, our team is ready to deliver the same five-star experience you’ve read about here. We offer free, no-obligation estimates and will walk you through every option clearly and honestly.
Call us today at (914) 924-4869 to schedule your free estimate and find out firsthand why On Time Roofing is New Rochelle’s most trusted roofing contractor. We look forward to earning your five-star review.
